Major League Soccer
Winners
- 1996 – DC United
- 1997 – DC United
- 1998 – Chicago Fire
- 1999 – DC United
- 2000 – Kansas City Wizards
- 2001 – San Jose Earthquakes
- 2002 – LA Galaxy
- 2003 – San Jose Earthquakes
- 2004 – DC United
- 2005 – LA Galaxy
- 2006 – Houston Dynamo
- 2007 – Houston Dynamo
- 2008 – Columbus Crew
- 2009 – Real Salt Lake
- 2010 – Colorado Rapids
- 2011 – LA Galaxy
- 2012 – LA Galaxy