Football League Two
- 2004/05 – Yeovil Town
- 2005/06 – Carlisle United
- 2006/07 – Walsall
- 2007/08 – Milton Keynes Dons
- 2008/09 – Brentford
- 2009/10 – Notts County
- 2010/11 – Chesterfield
- 2011/12 – Swindon Town
- 2012/13 – Gillingham