Conference Premier
Winners
- 1979/80 – Altrincham FC
- 1980/81 – Altrincham FC
- 1981/82 – Runcorn FC
- 1982/83 – Enfield FC
- 1983/84 – Maidstone United
- 1984/85 – Wealdstone
- 1985/86 – Enfield FC
- 1986/87 – Scarborough
- 1987/88 – Lincoln City
- 1988/89 – Maidstone United
- 1989/90 – Darlington FC
- 1990/91 – Barnet FC
- 1991/92 – Colchester United
- 1992/93 – Wycombe Wanderers
- 1993/94 – Kidderminster Harriers
- 1994/95 – Macclesfield Town
- 1995/96 – Stevenage Borough
- 1996/97 – Macclesfield Town
- 1997/98 – Halifax Town
- 1998/99 – Cheltenham Town
- 1999/00 – Kidderminster Harriers
- 2000/01 – Rushden & Diamonds
- 2001/02 – Boston United
- 2002/03 – Yeovil Town
- 2003/04 – Chester City
- 2004/05 – Barnet FC
- 2005/06 – Accrington Stanley
- 2006/07 – Dagenham & Redbridge
- 2007/08 – Aldershot Town
- 2008/09 – Burton Albion
- 2009/10 – Stevenage Borough
- 2010/11 – Crawley Town
- 2011/12 – Fleetwood Town
- 2012/13 – Mansfield Town